Lobster Trap: "Locally Caught Seafood" Santa Catalina Island Restaurant Tip by atufft

Santa Catalina Island Restaurants: 19 reviews and 27 photos

  Lobster Trap Restaurant, Catalina Island, CA
by atufft
 
  • Lobster Trap Restaurant, Catalina Island, CA - Santa Catalina Island
      Lobster Trap Restaurant, Catalina Island, CA
    by atufft
  • Lobster Trap Restaurant, Catalina Island, CA - Santa Catalina Island
      Lobster Trap Restaurant, Catalina Island, CA
    by atufft
  • Lobster Trap Restaurant, Catalina Island, CA - Santa Catalina Island
      Lobster Trap Restaurant, Catalina Island, CA
    by atufft
 

The local food here is seafood, although my host frequently prefers a steak--also widely available on the island. Fortunately, the Lobster Trap has a diverse menu for locals in a sports bar atmosphere. The restaurant is located on the corner of 3rd and Catalina Ave, a block off the beach, and so it's not generally crowded with tourists wanting a view of the ocean. But, as the website claims, the food is the town's best deal, particularly for it's fish which is locally caught by the owner! There are some really great dinner plates, but I was stunned by the crafted Yellowtail sandwich that I ordered. Sorry no photo of the food, as at the time we were just getting introduced to each other after the ferry boat ride. Don't miss this place. It's authentic Avalon hometown food. There are pool tables and darts for those wanting sports bar entertainment, so this is also a great place to rub elbows with those service workers who know most about the island.

Favorite Dish: Take your pick. Avalon residents have a sophisticated palate, but there's also hamburgers and chicken with pasta. The beer and wine list is excellent, and cheap in price. Ask about the fresh catch and go from there. My avocado and yellowtail sandwich was served on a sourdough kaiser bun, and was outstanding. Also, the service here is equally outstanding. The is one of the least expensive places in town too.

Address: Corner of 3rd and Catalina Avenue
Comparison: less expensive than average
Directions: Across from the Tour Bus Depot. You can't miss it.
Price: US$11-20
Rating: 5
Theme: Local
Website: http://catalinalobstertrap.com/

Review Helpfulness: 3.5 out of 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

  • Updated Apr 11, 2012
  • Send to a Friend
  • Report Abuse

Comments

atufft

“California is on the edge of the planet, not the center of the universe”

Online Now

Male

Top 1,000 Travel Writer
Member Rank:
0 0 0 5 5
Forum Rank:
0 0 2 2 6

Have you been to Santa Catalina Island?

  Share Your Travels