Blue Heaven: "Exellent Restaurant in Old Key West" Blue Heaven Tip by TooTallFinn24

Blue Heaven, Key West: 26 reviews and 29 photos

  Outside Eating Area at the Blue Heaven Key West
by TooTallFinn24
  • Outside Eating Area at the Blue Heaven Key West - Key West
      Outside Eating Area at the Blue Heaven Key West
    by TooTallFinn24
  • Blue Heaven Dining Area - Key West
      Blue Heaven Dining Area
    by TooTallFinn24

We were traveling on foot and the restaurant which is located on the 700 block of Thomas Street is not easy to find. However once you do it is well worth the walk.
The Blue Heaven, whose seating is outside, is like sitting in a neighbor's farm back yard. The seating is casual and there are all sorts of chickens and cats roaming the backyard. While it sounds irritating it is actually quite relaxing.

We ordered the Jamaican Chicken Jerk Sandwich and the Shrimp Sandwich. The chicken sandwich consists of strips of chicken breast marinated in a delightful concoction of spices. It is served on a bun. The The Shrimp Sandwich is actually a shrimp melt on a fresh bun topped off with cheddar cheese. The waiter indicated that the shrimp is caught locally. It tasted fresh and was a joy to eat.

For desert the key lime pie served here is out of this world. It tastes like it was just prepared a few minutes ago and has the crisp taste of limes and just a nice addition of whipped cream.

Favorite Dish: Shrimp sandwich with cheese, and the fantastic key lime pie. Even the ice tea which they bring plenty of is tasty and refreshing. Basically you cant go wrong at this restaurant!

Address: 729 Thomas St.
Price Comparison: about average
Directions: Corner of Petronia & Thomas
Phone: 305.296.8666
Price: US$21-30
Rating: 5
Theme: Local

Review Helpfulness: 3.5 out of 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

  • Written Sep 18, 2011
  • Send to a Friend
  • Add to your Trip Planner
  • Report Abuse



“Travel is the only thing you can buy that makes you richer.”

Online Now


Top 1,000 Travel Writer
Member Rank:
0 0 2 7 4
Forum Rank:
0 0 0 3 5

Have you been to Key West?

  Share Your Travels