"Darwin’s nightmare?" Top 5 Page for this destination Danau Toba Warnings Or Dangers Tip by kokoryko

Danau Toba Warnings and Dangers: 2 reviews and 5 photos

  Fishfarms pontons. .
by kokoryko
  • Fishfarms pontons. . - Danau Toba
      Fishfarms pontons. .
    by kokoryko
  • Other pontons - Danau Toba
      Other pontons
    by kokoryko
  • Green hills of Samosir - Danau Toba
      Green hills of Samosir
    by kokoryko
  • aerial view of a fishfarm - Danau Toba
      aerial view of a fishfarm
    by kokoryko
  • Going to work - Danau Toba
      Going to work
    by kokoryko

Warning and danger? Danger is for the lake, possibly, but if the lake dies, the people will leave, and finally there will not even be visiting tourists. . .

Darwin’s nightmare; if you do not know, I just can very very warmly recommend you to leave VT for an evening and watch this movie; you will look at the world and people with different eyes! A synopsis of the documentary film is here: http://www.darwinsnightmare.com/. You also can watch (low quality) on google video : http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=9039818938732594749
But. . . what has this story to do with North Sumatra? Well, when I had looks from far at some fish farms, I remembered that movie; and when I visited Ambarita, locals told me about fish farmers or agronomists, “experts” coming from Europe to implement fish farms and having seen what fish farming can do (to the environment, to the people; . . ) I suddenly felt unwell. I did not see horrors, I do not know if there are, may be all is well in the waters of Lake Toba and on its shores. . . . I just could see from far, installations which looked clean. . . Cannot tell more, just can be scared a bit.

There is not a lot in the press about that subject; here are two links.


Well, finally it may not be a nightmare here, and the waters of the lake are preserved. . .
You see on the first picture pontoons and cabins of farms, by tens in some places, with the pontoons reaching the shore (picture 2). So, if you see lots of cabins near the shores under the green hills of Samosir, these are not for tourists going for a bath(picture 3); you have a better idea of how the fish farms look like, when you look from above, like here, in a bay next to Parapat (picture 4), and many of these floating farms can only be reached by boat (picture 5)

Review Helpfulness: 3.5 out of 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

  • Updated Jun 12, 2009
  • Send to a Friend
  • Add to your Trip Planner
  • Report Abuse



“Il me plait de courir sans but et sans raison . . . .”

Online Now


Top 1,000 Travel Writer
Member Rank:
0 0 0 6 7
Forum Rank:
0 0 3 5 9

Have you been to Danau Toba?

  Share Your Travels