will close on Feb 27th.

Please save any personal content and exchange contact info with other members you?d like to stay in touch with. Thank you for your contributions to the VirtualTourist community.

The Sugar Shack: "Lousy service and bad ice cream" Tybee Island Restaurant Tip by Calliehan

Tybee Island Restaurants: 25 reviews and 19 photos

The cashiers were a couple of tough-talking guys. The elderly couple in front of us had asked to taste a few things and were a little indecisive, but not extremely so. When they had finally made a selection the said--and I kid you not--"Cup, cone, or on your head?"

When it was my turn, I asked to try the Key Lime Pie ice cream and he said, "We don't really give samples" even though they had just given samples to the people in front of us and there was no one behind us. I asked "How is the Key Lime Pie ice cream?" and he said, "Just like you'd expect Key Lime Pie ice cream to be. It tastes like Key Lime Pie, but it's ice cream."

The ice cream had a strong freezer taste...and a crystally/icy texture. Rotten, rotten, rotten.

Don't waste your time.

Favorite Dish: I didn't have anything that I would recommend.

Address: On the main drag
Price Comparison: about average
Directions: At the curve, just as you are coming into Tybee proper
Price: less than US$10
Rating: 1
Theme: Ice Cream

Review Helpfulness: 2.5 out of 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

  • Written May 7, 2008
  • Send to a Friend
  • Add to your Trip Planner
  • Report Abuse


Ranked Member
Member Rank:
2 5 3 4 9

Have you been to Tybee Island?

  Share Your Travels