Matteo's Ristorante Italiano--NOBLESVILLE, IN: "Matteo's Ristorante---A Reason To Escape the City" Top 5 Page for this destination Indiana Restaurant Tip by pabertra

Indiana Restaurants: 59 reviews and 67 photos

  The Bar Has A Great Mural
by pabertra
  • The Bar Has A Great Mural - Indiana
      The Bar Has A Great Mural
    by pabertra
  • Inside Matteo's Art & Ambience - Indiana
      Inside Matteo's Art & Ambience
    by pabertra
  • A Great Wine Bar - Indiana
      A Great Wine Bar
    by pabertra
  • Map to Matteo's - Indiana
      Map to Matteo's
    by pabertra

Matteo's is a great escape from the hustle of the city. The ristorante is located in the heart of downtown Noblesville amongst many trendy shops and cafes that surround the stunning Hamilton County Courthouse. Enter into Matteo's and the charm doesn't stop the walls are painted a comforting shade of pumpkin and classic Dean Martin music creates a warm and sophisticated feel. The outstanding food and glasses of Chianti filled to the brim make the experience one you'll wish to relive time and time again. The highlight of the perfect dining experience? Bananas Foster prepared tableside by a true New Orleans chef...Fantastico!

Favorite Dish:

My boyfriend & I enjoyed the following:

Bread & Infused Olive Oil

Bottle of Unfiltered Tuscan Wine (Not sure what kind)

Waiter recommended an unfiltered Tuscan was a little too robust for such a meal with the heavy peppery taste seeming to overpower our food...stick to the Chianti!

Tagliatella Alla Tarantella-$13.95

Fettuccine pasta cooked with homemade chicken sausage, garlic, fresh asparagus, sun dried tomatoes and a white wine cream sauce. Delicious flavor!

I had something similar to Fruit de La Mer or Seafood Bouillabaisse that was a house special

Mussels, Sauteed Calamari, & Gulf Shrimp set over a bed of spaghetti with a tomato broth, needed some extra spice...wish I had opted for the infamous lasagna.

Bananas Foster--?

Not on the menu, but ALWAYS available and definitely the best dessert option if only for the presentation, but the taste is incredible! Prepared tableside by a true New Orleans chef.

Overall the ambience, reasonably priced food, and great dessert won me over! I'll be back to try the infamous lasagna.

Address: 40 N 9th St (Noblesville, IN)
Price Comparison: more expensive than average
Directions: See map under additional pictures.
Phone: (317)-774-9771
Price: US$31-40
Rating: 4
Theme: Italian

Review Helpfulness: 2 out of 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

  • Updated Dec 21, 2006
  • Send to a Friend
  • Add to your Trip Planner
  • Report Abuse


pabertra Used To Live Here!


“~T~ake R~isks A~d~V~entures and most of all E~njoy L~ife---TRAVEL”

Online Now


Top 1,000 Travel Writer
Member Rank:
0 0 5 8 6

Have you been to Indiana?

  Share Your Travels