Berea Restaurant Tips by Krumlovgirl Top 5 Page for this destination
Berea Restaurants: 12 reviews and 7 photos
I’ve been eating at this place for nearly 17 years now. And, unfortunately, I’ve been ordering the same thing. Hot ham and cheese on homemade bread or a bowl of Wisconsin cheese soup. I don’t know why. Habit, maybe? But anyway, this is a great little place on College Square, around the corner from Boone Tavern. It’s a very old world kind of restaurant with wooden booths and dark corners and has become a favorite with the college crowd. If you’re in the mood for pizza, subs, or pasta, it’s definitely the place to go in Berea.
Favorite Dish: There are a few dishes that I like...the Wisconsin cheese soup is good, but strong so stay away if you don't like harsh cheese. The hot ham and cheese on Papa Leno's bread is good and comes with a side of potatoe chips and a pickle. The baked spaghetti with meat sauce is excellent and comes with a huge garlic bread stick that is nice to dip into the meat sauce. For dessert, there is the chocolate suicide cake (it's as rich as it looks) and the turtle cheesecake, my favorite.
Address: 108 Center Street
Comparison: less expensive than average
Directions: Located on College Square
Other Contact: jlewis1329@aol.com
Phone: 859-986-4497
Price: less than US$10
Rating: 4
Theme: Italian
Located at the top of the Old Town Arts District in Berea, Coffee Conspiracy is a place for specialty coffee, food, and live music. Old world motif, high ceilings, art and photography adorn the walls. Not just hot coffee-they also serve smooth blended ice coffee drinks and fruit smoothies. Definitely the hangout for the young, intellectual crowd.
Address: 440 Chestnut Street
Comparison: least expensive
Other Contact: coffeeconspiracy@msn.com
Phone: (859) 986-8597
Price: less than US$10
Rating: 4
Theme: Coffeehouse
Website: http://www.coffeeconspiracy.com
Some people think that this place is too high for the area, but it's about as much as Graetter's or White Mountain Creamery. I guess it just takes the local people time to warm up to a new place-especially since in the past the only place to get ice cream at has been Dairy Queen and Sonic.
Favorite Dish: I think it's a good place as far as ice cream goes. And I'm a huge ice cream fan. It's cute and they're trying to make a nice atmosphere with the outdoor seating and "vintage" feel to it. And anyway-it's ice cream! What's not to like?
Address: 636 Chestnut St
Comparison: least expensive
Other Contact: jupton@mis.net
Phone: 859-986-6633
Price: less than US$10
Rating: 4
Theme: Ice Cream
A local hangout (especially for the people at my workplace), Mario's has something for everyone. Pizza, pasta, salads, subs-and that's just for the Italian side. They also have burgers, fries, and baked potatoes. And then there's the Mexican menu. Go for the buffet-you get more for your money.
Favorite Dish: I really like their baked ziti. The cheese on top is soft and creamy. A lot of times the ziti is over (or under) cooked and it has a hard taste to it. This place has just about mastered it. The people I work with like the burgers, but I don't care much for the bread they put them on. I guess it's all just a matter of taste.
Address: 636 Chestnut St
Comparison: least expensive
Other Contact: jupton@mis.net
Phone: 859-986-2331
Price: less than US$10
Rating: 4
Theme: Other
This is the place to eat at when you're feeling like something a little more upscale than the Dinner Bell. Used to, it was black tie, but now you can find people dining in jeans. Personally, I miss the old days...But anyway. It's definitely the most expensive restaurant in Berea, and quite possibly the county. It's still elegant and refined and the food above par.
Favorite Dish: I love the spoonbread that comes with every meal. It's basically soft corn bread with a little sweet taste. For meals, you can't go wrong with any of the meat dishes, and the baked Alaska is a great dessert when they have it.
Address: 100 Main Street
Comparison: most expensive
Phone: 859-985-3700
Price: US$21-30
Rating: 4
Theme: Local
Website: http://www.boonetavernhotel.com/
More Reviews (30)
Berea Travel Guide
Member Travel Pages
- "Berea- Arts Capital of Kentucky"
- "Berea, KY.... Folk Craft Capital"
- "Berea, Kentucky: College Town & Folk Arts Capital"
- "Berea is beautiful"
- "The Arts and Craft Center of Kentucky"
- "Ky_Happy_Dad's new Berea Page"
- "Stuart_A_Ray's new Berea page"
- See All...
Explore the World
- Three Jolly Pigeons Hotels
- Oostzaan Hotels
- Sveti Lovrec Pazenaticki Hotels
- Millmerran Hotels
- Esmeraldas
- Evanston
- Petworth
- Tenby
Krumlovgirl Visits Here Frequently!
Krumlovgirl
“I dream of a better tomorrow when chickens can cross the road without having their movtives questioned.”
![]()
![]()
- Member Rank:
- 0 0 2 4 7
- 623 Reviews
- 2,950 Photos
- Add Friend
- Follow
- Send Message
Badges & Stats in Berea
- 35 Reviews
- 71 Photos
- 0 Forum posts
- 6 Comments
- 7,357PageViews
- See All Stats
- See All Badges (15)
Have you been to Berea?
Share Your TravelsLatest Activity in Berea
- Wrote a Review Eco-friendly and comfortable in Berea Hotels
- Posted in Miscellaneous Forum "Re: Most....."
- updated a Berea Travel Page "Berea- Arts Capital of Kentucky"
- Uploaded a Photo to "Photos of Berea"
Top 10 Pages
-
Richmond
Intro, 90 reviews, 196 photos, 7 travelogues
-
Top 5 Page for this destination
Lexington
Intro, 47 reviews, 104 photos, 6 travelogues
-
Top 5 Page for this destination
Kentucky
Intro, 26 reviews, 122 photos, 6 travelogues
-
Prague
Intro, 42 reviews, 100 photos, 5 travelogues
-
Top 5 Page for this destination
Berea
Intro, 35 reviews, 77 photos, 5 travelogues
-
Boston
Intro, 21 reviews, 57 photos, 5 travelogues
-
Lampeter
Intro, 8 reviews, 65 photos, 5 travelogues
-
Top 5 Page for this destination
Glastonbury
Intro, 9 reviews, 63 photos, 5 travelogues
-
Las Vegas
Intro, 26 reviews, 44 photos, 1 travelogue
-
London
Intro, 16 reviews, 52 photos, 4 travelogues
Latest Berea hotel reviews
- Boone Tavern Hotel
- 147 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 22, 2013 - Fairfield Inn & Suites Berea
- 43 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: Apr 30, 2013 - Comfort Inn & Suites
- 67 Reviews & Opinions
Latest: May 6, 2013


Theme Park Trips
Budget Travel
Backpacking